GUILTY: Jury Convicts Hagan of Murder

WARRICK CO. -- A jury in Warrick County has found 23-year-old Isaiah Hagan guilty in the murder of college student Halee Rathgeber last year.

The day began with closing arguments in the morning, followed by jury deliberation and, after just a few hours, the jurors returned that guilty verdict.

The second phase of the trial begins Thursday when the jury will hear arguments to decide whether or not Hagan should be sentenced to life without parole.